A 3-unit walk-up apartment building on the Staten Island record, built in 1901.
251 Castleton Avenue is a 3-unit building in Staten Island, New York City (BBL 5001190095). This building is associated with Chiarello, John. Brix tracks 0 open HPD violations for this property, along with inspection history, DOB filings, tenant complaints, and rent stabilization status.
Built in 1901, this walk-up apartment building sits in Staten Island and is tracked by Brix using public NYC records from HPD, DOB, ACRIS, and 311.
Tenants have filed 8 HPD complaints about this building over the last five years, most often about unsanitary condition.
What tenants have called the city about here over the last five years:
The most recent complaint on this building was filed January 8, 2026.
The building last changed hands on May 12, 2026, according to recorded deeds.
Brix rating: Take a closer look (70/100). View the full report on Brix.
See every NYC building owned by Chiarello, John on the landlord portfolio page.
Part of St. George — see violations, complaints, and landlord activity across the whole neighborhood.
Other buildings in 10301:
Browse every NYC neighborhood or the landlord directory on Brix.