A Sutton Place condo with a heavy sponsor presence and a lingering issue with indoor air quality.
Vintage Real Estate Services manages, and the sponsor is actively unloading units. But residents are dealing with some persistent indoor odors. Three things to know:
A stack of complaints about indoor air quality. Residents have filed 19 smoking or vaping complaints and 15 indoor air quality reports directly from the building. These kinds of numbers usually indicate that air is traveling between apartments, likely due to aging ventilation systems or shared shafts.
Sponsor sales are dominating the building's turnover. Across the entire condo declaration, there were 41 sales in the last year, with 16 of those sold by the sponsor, Sutton 58 Holding Company LLC. One unit went to an LLC for $6.65M in January 2026. A sponsor with this much inventory holds significant sway over board decisions, budgets, and common charge assessments.
The building carries unresolved housing-code violations. The building carries four open violations. While none are currently classified as immediately hazardous, open violations are essentially deferred capital work that can stall unit sales or refinancings. They remain the board's responsibility to clear.
Quieter signals on this building and the blocks around it:
420 East 58th Street is a 75-unit building in Manhattan, New York City (BBL 1013697501). This building is associated with 420 East 58th Street Condomimium. Brix tracks 3 open HPD violations for this property, along with inspection history, DOB filings, tenant complaints, and rent stabilization status.
Built in 1986, this condominium sits in Manhattan and is tracked by Brix using public NYC records from HPD, DOB, ACRIS, and 311.
Tenants have filed 4 HPD complaints about this building over the last five years, most often about heat/hot water.
What tenants have called the city about here over the last five years:
The most recent complaint on this building was filed December 21, 2024.
Conditions cited on open violations at this address:
The building last changed hands on March 27, 2026 for $2,287,506.25, according to recorded deeds.
Brix score: 50/100. View the Building Report on Brix.
See every NYC building owned by 420 East 58th Street Condomimium on the landlord portfolio page.
Part of Midtown East — see violations, complaints, and landlord activity across the whole neighborhood.
Other buildings in 10022:
Browse every NYC neighborhood or the landlord directory on Brix.
Unit 26B at 420 East 58th Street has 2 open violations, last sold in 2004 for $700K. Owner on the latest deed: Ag26b LLC.
Unit 7F at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2026 for $1.2M. Owner on the latest deed: Arendt, Matthew & Misson, Thomas.
Unit 18A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2026 for $4.7M. Owner on the latest deed: Brotman, Laurie & Brotman, Andrew.
Unit 1C at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2026 for $725K. Owner on the latest deed: Mansur, Bishara.
Unit 2E at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2026 for $645K. Owner on the latest deed: Baxter, Kelly.
Unit 15BC at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2026 for $2.5M. Owner on the latest deed: Pablo Torre, Trustee & Elizabeth Doherty, Trustee +1 more.
Unit 6E at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2024 for $566K. Owner on the latest deed: Rufino, Co-Trustee, Robert S. & The Robert S. Rufino Living Trust.
Unit 2A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2023 for $1.6M. Owner on the latest deed: Sherri R Stewart Rev Trust Dated 2/5/2025 & Sherri R Stewart, Trustee.
Unit 10CD at 420 East 58th Street has no violations. Owner on the latest deed: LJM Irrevocable Trust & Theodore Leighton Moy As Trustee.
Unit 14B at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.6M. Owner on the latest deed: Tetrault, Amanda.
Unit 2G at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2022 for $575K. Owner on the latest deed: Wright - Trabanco Family Trust, DTD. 8-19-2025.
Unit 6D at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $795K. Owner on the latest deed: Kevin R. Carroll Living Trust & Carroll, Trustee, Kevin R.
Unit 7C at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $379K. Owner on the latest deed: Stone, Deborah.
Unit 2F at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.1M. Owner on the latest deed: Disilvestro, Adam & Osman, Sana.
Unit 11A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $2.3M. Owner on the latest deed: Freudenheim, Julie & Feldman, Spencer.
Unit 12A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $902K. Owner on the latest deed: Weldon, Matthew & Carrera, Gallegos.
Unit 14G at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $599K. Owner on the latest deed: Zhang, Tony & Shan, Sherry +1 more.
Unit 6A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.7M. Owner on the latest deed: Woodman, Clare & Potter, Colin.
Unit 2B at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.2M. Owner on the latest deed: Tien, Ellen & Tien-Dana, James.
Unit 21A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $3.9M. Owner on the latest deed: Javara Ltd..
Unit 10G at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $26M. Owner on the latest deed: Blazing Star Parent LLC.
Unit 22A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $863K. Owner on the latest deed: Dalia Gordon Revocable Trust & Mark Gordon Revocable Trust +2 more.
Unit 15B at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.6M. Owner on the latest deed: Hammond, John.
Unit 1A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.9M. Owner on the latest deed: Viscogliosi, Anthony.
Unit WM at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.9M. Owner on the latest deed: Duffey JR, Nevin & Duffey, Jenny.
Unit 14C at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $1.1M. Owner on the latest deed: Brown, Nancy & Brown, Jessica.
Unit 8B at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2024 for $1.3M. Owner on the latest deed: Virginia Goodman-Futterman Revocable Trust.
Unit 26A at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $4.1M. Owner on the latest deed: Truenorth Ventures LLC.
Unit 4C at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $950K. Owner on the latest deed: Treacy, Susanna & Wiegand, Nicholas.
Unit 9C at 420 East 58th Street has no violations, last sold in 2025 for $410K. Owner on the latest deed: Sandra Ginsburg Revocable Trust & Kirsten E. Levy, Trustee.
Showing 30 of 176 apartments with records. Open the report to search every apartment.
Own or manage this building? Monitor it or correct the record.